Wednesday, August 25, 2010

Time for Some Practical

Here is the first question in a series of questions trying to move from philosophical/theoretical to practical.

Question: What components must be part of a sermon for it to really be a sermon?

Think in terms of the differences between discussion groups, small group Bible studies, etc. What are the necessary components to a sermon. I'll start with the obvious: opening the Bible. What else?

Monday, August 2, 2010

The Beginning of Something...

So if you found this page then you probably know something about me and the things I'm thinking (or you spend way too much time online!). Anyhow, this particular blog exists to explore the idea of the preaching task and how it relates to the 21st century. Let me begin by saying that I am a fan of preaching. I was raised on preaching, went to school to learn preaching, have spent a number of years preaching, and think that I even possess gifts related to preaching (at least that's what people keep telling me!). All that to say, I am not looking to eliminate preaching from church life. However-- and here's where we need to be honest-- I struggle to see much relevancy in typical contemporary preaching. Is preaching actually accomplishing anything?

Doug Pagitt describes most modern preaching as "speeching". He sees what happens in 99% of churches as pastors making speeches based on religious content. Honestly, I have to agree. A monologue that has been prepared in solitude, delivered in 30 minutes, and protected from feedback/questions/disagreement is really closer to a speech than anything else. (Pagitt makes the point, though, that even most speeches give opportunity for rebuttal whereas sermons do not). He also notes that this 'Speeching' really only developed in the last couple centuries, since the Enlightenment and the dawn of the industrial revolution. (If you really want to engage in this dialogue picking up and reading his book "Preaching Re-Imagined" would be super helpful.)

So what does all this mean for preaching? If we were developing 'church' from scratch (without a couple hundred years of modernism as the model) what would the preaching task look like? What is successful preaching? Is it occurring anywhere today? What would it look like for you to look forward to the sermon each week? Should it continue to be a monologue, should it become a discussion, or should it evolve to something all together different? How does the larger church community participate? Should they? How does the sermon keep from being 30 awkward minutes separate from the rest of your existence that will be promptly forgotten after lunch? how could we rethink preaching so that it is a valuable, effective, formative element of community life?

Thoughts?