New question: Who are you favorite preachers and why? Be specific!
Also, I'm working my way through a few different books on the history of preaching. So far the consensus is that what we typically experience as a sermon, or what we stereotype as a sermon, does not find its root in the Bible or in NT church meetings. In other words, the 'sermon' as we experience it today (i.e. 30 -60 minute monologue, intellectually based, logically formatted, information download, etc) was a later invention. Got any thoughts on that?
After I read your question I tried to think about how Jesus did it, how did He communicate to individuals as well as groups that followed Him and this thought came to mind...most of the time I think He communicated in stories/parables. It seems that He had a goal to make the person or group think and or to bring them along with Him on the journey of discovery. It wasn’t about telling them how to believe but creatively getting them to that place where they get it and choose to believe. I feel that His stories were not just cute or interesting antidotes that He thought would help prove an idea or point but they were stories that had a purpose which was to connect to the listener and I think He was very intentional in the content of His stories/parables. They were not random and nebulous but dealt with things that would have meaning/connection to the listener. For example when He talks about gardening, soil, bearing fruit, He as the vine etc. this connected to a culture that’s livelihood was solely based on cultivating the land. They understood about seeds that when planted in good soil grow, those that land in rocks or hard land do not etc. I think this idea is also true of the times in Scripture where it may seem that He is more or less “preaching” to the group/crowd. It seemed that His whole focus/goal was to bring them on a journey with Him not just to tell them the information we needed. As far as this and the model of “preaching” today, my thought is that very much of the time it seems as though the pastor has put so much time into preparing His sermon and focusing on how to best relay the information that he has worked so hard on that it ends up coming across as a lesson/lecture rather than him in his personal study finding something so eye opening to him all he wants to do is pass it on. What he has discovered and wants to share has so opened his eyes to the Scripture or who God is that all he wants to do is take us on a journey to explore it with him and maybe be as amazed as he was. An example of this was last Sunday, Chris preached on why were the disciples so willing to drop everything and follow Jesus when asked. The passages he read are ones that I have read/heard a million times. What made is so amazing and come alive what that Chris provided historical back round about Jewish school, the different levels and how this related to why for these men to be called by a Rabbi was life changing for them. Jesus gave them a second chance and told them that He saw potential in them. I was left with the idea that when Jesus called me to follow Him, He too saw potential in me. Wow!
ReplyDeleteWould love to see today's sermons more about a journey together rather than what at times seems like an information download.
Just my thoughts...hope they make sense!!!
Absolutely makes sense.
ReplyDeleteOne of the things you are touching on (at least it seems to me) is the relational aspects of the "preaching task". It seems that during the Enlightenment, when much of what we see in sermons today was developed, it became part of the culture to separate preaching from relationship. In other words, it was the 'knowledge' we were after and the relationship between preacher and listener had little to do with the preaching act (thus situations like roving/circuit rider preachers, evangelistic crusades, etc developed). I think the concept of a journey (like you describe) is that relationship between preacher and listener that does not always exist in contemporary churches.
Good stuff!
This is Tonya...I have come in contact with some great pastors and the common thread has been...Read the word, what does that mean, how to apply this to my life, practical ideas on how to go forth and do this.
ReplyDeleteTonya, I too love it when Pastors give us practical ideas on how to live. It is so easy to sit and listen and then walk away feeling lost as to how to implement the concepts in my life. I think that it all goes back to walking the journey together!
ReplyDeleteSounds pretty simple to me, Tonya. Do you think most churches experience this on Sunday mornings? Also, do you think most listeners have the same idea as you do in terms of what makes a good preacher?
ReplyDeleteI have recently heard Britt Merrick's sermons and have felt that I learned so much about how to live as a believer. He speaks from the Word and works on applying it to our lives. When the sermon is over you feel loved by God, humbled to be so loved, and impressed by the need to go out and live in a way that honors Him. Britt loves the Lord, speaks to us honestly, admits his shortfalls, is not afraid to speak the truth, and doesn't worry about limiting his sermons--they often last 45 minutes or more and I am never bored. I have to say that I look forward to certain guest speakers when I know they are coming to Calvary. And I remember things I learned from them even years ago. Why? They kept it simple (Full serve/self serve--even my 8 year old talks about that image, or God as an Epic storyteller), they incorporated visuals/music (David Crowder or other videos like the ping pong ball, Casting Crowns lyrics), and they answered questions/spoke to issues I need to understand and that people around me seek to understand. They also spoke from personal experiences, often painful or funny, that helped me see they and their lives aren't perfect, but they walk with God and learn as they go. Paula
ReplyDeleteSo, Paula, if I synthesized your post, would it be fair to say you would list the following as important in 'good preaching'?
ReplyDelete- authenticity
- simple (memorable short statements'
- practical/application oriented
- relevant
Did I put words in your mouth or miss something?
This is good stuff so far!
ReplyDeleteI was going to put a few quotes in from "Lectures to My Students" by C.H. Spurgeon, since he had some good things to say about "sermons" in chapter 5 - but there were so many good points, I think I will just recommend the whole chapter! You can read it several places online (including google books), but here is one link:
http://spurgeonspeaks.blogspot.com/2009/09/lectures-to-my-students-5-sermons-their.html
Thanks Jeff, I'll read chapter 5 later today.
ReplyDeletesorry if this posts twice (one as my profile, one as anonymous, it's PBJ/James) it's acting weird
ReplyDeletethe danger, or maybe better said difficulty, of spelling out the practical implications are
1) limiting the scope too much to just what I think or see...ex. love your neighbor = taking them iced tea on a hot day, so I can check that off, I've loved them, while I flip them off on the way out of the driveway cause their dog pooped on my lawn
2) being wrong...ex. dressing modestly clearly means girs can't wear jeans, etc.
preachers I've liked...this will completely useless...I've liked good preachers :-). I think it's when they are Bible focused but they're good enough their speaking style doesn't get in the way (boring, hard to follow, etc.). Some have been plain and simple, some have been scholarly and challenging but not like a history lecture.
Ones I enjoy most...Francis Chan, Alistair Begg, some dude at Biola but I can't remember his name, my dad, Pastor Duane (biased on the last two)...when you have a good pastor, lectures don't seem like lectures and hearing them weekly is something you look forward to...when you have a bad pastor it's brutal.
Style of sermon...Jesus did a lot of lecturing even as he told stories and interacted...Sermon on the Mount is long if listening, not reading, Upper Room Discourse is long (John 13-17?) and not so interactive at the end, and don't forget about him lecturing them in the Garden, oh wait, different kind of lecture.
The rest of the Bible has it's fair share of lectures too...several times the whole nation is standing outside reading/listening to the whole law.
Part of the problem, maybe more than lecturing, is that a lot of guys in the pulpit shouldn't be due to either lack of skill or lack of Bible use.
That said, the more the interaction the better, even if it's only mental interaction.
Thanks James. I agree that there is a danger with preachers getting too specific in their practical application of the sermon. At the very least the danger is that there could be (probably is) a much better practical application for you that I could not possible have thought of before hand. Even worse could be that preachers end up creating a congregation that looks to the pastor to provide them the specific application possibilities, as opposed to grappling with Scripture themselves, or relying on the Holy Spirit.
ReplyDeleteOn another note, I think I disagree with your statement "Jesus did a lot of lecturing...". I don't see this even in the "Sermon" on the Mount or the Upper Room Discourse. Both of these seem to be in the context of questions asked and answers given; something much more like a conversation that a monologue. However, your point about the OT times when the Law was read to a standing congregation leans much more towards a 'one person talking' situation. However, the speaker is God through His Word which I would argue is much 'better' to be subjected to for a long period of time as opposed to a pastor's interpretation/explanation of God's Word. If extended readings of the Bible became the central focus of the sermon, a monologue could be acceptable. However, this is not the reality. Long sermons are almost exclusively monologues built on the preachers explanation of a short Scripture passage.
Thoughts?
James again
ReplyDeletestill think Jesus was lecturing there but even if He was, as you point out with the OT it was God's word not Moses' thoughts...very different
I think "wholly agree with your last paragraph" might apply...too little scripture (and too short a passage) very much applies to today's sermons either with little substance (typically called topical) or supposedly lots of substance (typically called expository) but a only a verse or two at a time.
I don't really like the expository/topical break down but whichever it is, if it isn't primarily Bible it isn't really preaching/teaching
Novel thought/question...perhaps part of the problem is trying to fit God's word into 30 minutes, what if sometimes it takes 5 mintues and others it takes 3 hours (like reading the OT law)?
I like your "thought/questions"... I agree that Western Culture is very much focused on the time issue, we tend to do that as opposed to more relational cultures. There seems to be two solutions to this: 1) Fight culture and allow the sermon to go on for as long as "it needs to" (the idea of 5 minutes or 3 hours), or 2) Preachers become more realistic with their allotted time. I lean towards the second one. It seems that often the preacher tries to fit too much into the time slot. I'm not sure the actual amount of time matters, whether it is 30 minutes or 1 hour, a preacher who has too many ideas to fit into the time comes across poorly. Better to separate it out into multiple sermons; give me one thing to chew on and give me another thing the following week. If nothing else this approach seems to gel with our contemporary culture where all information is broken down into bite-size chunks. Love it or hate it, doesn't matter, it is reality. Sorry, I think I digressed here...
ReplyDelete