A friend passed this little story on to me, and it does seem related to our conversation. Especially in light of some of my initial comments about a seemingly very little return from the vast investment of time, money, and energy that goes into sermon making. So I thought I'd post it here and see what you think about it:
Why Go To Church?
A Church goer wrote a letter to the editor of a newspaper and complained that it made no sense to go to church every Sunday. "I've gone for 30 years now," he wrote, "and in that time I have heard something like 3,000 sermons. But for the life of me, I can't remember a single one of them. So, I think I'm wasting my time and the pastors are wasting theirs by giving sermons at all."
This started a real controversy in the "Letters to the Editor" column, much to the delight of the editor. It went on for weeks until someone wrote this clincher:
"I've been married for 30 years now. In that time my wife has cooked some 32,000 meals. But, for the life of me, I cannot recall the entire menu for a single one of those meals. But I do know this.. They all nourished me and gave me the strength I needed to do my work. If my wife had not given me these meals, I would be physically dead today. Likewise, if I had not gone to church for nourishment, I would be spiritually dead today!"
Thoughts?
James/PBJ again - it really doesn't like me or something because it says I'm logged in but won't post comments under my account
ReplyDeleteGreat question (and really the place to start)
Love that final response because that is definitely a significant part of the answer
also part of the answer
Scriptures prescription and description...
Description - Acts clearly shows regular (in fact probably more often than weekly like us) church gathering, the rest of the NT does as well and the OT clearly set church involvement as the core of life for God's people...the example is clearly connectedness
Prescription - Heb 11 and others...do not give up meeting together, etc.
Follow Questions/Challenges
What should church be/look like in every facet including teaching/preaching God's word
I agree that the NT demonstrates that Christians meet together 'regularly' (which probably means more than once a week since many of them were still doing Synogogue, worship on Sunday in celebration of the risen Jesus, and maybe other times as well- 'love feasts', celebrations, etc). However, I'm also pretty convinces that these did not have anywhere near the shape of our modern Sunday Church service. As we've been interacting on this blog I've also been doing a ton of reading in this area. Suffice it to say, early Sunday Church services (1st and 2nd century) have very little (if any) structure. It seems it was truly more of a time when believers got together to celebrate Jesus and talk about Him. They did this with each other. It wasn't until the late 3rd (4th?) century that shape began to form (stemming from Christianity being given some legitimacy, purchase of buildings for churches, and the development of the Catholic institution). Preaching in particular developed most in this time. The common phrase we read is 'homily' which seems to be the pastor/priest attempt at teaching the Bible to people who either did not own one or could not read one (illiteracy developed in the early middle ages). This 'homily' probably was the precursor to our 'expository preaching' (read a verse, tell what it means) but the guys who did this seemed to employ all sorts of methods. Some were boring to death, others were creative and contemporary, even using cultural examples at times. What I've come away with in my reading is that while many 5th century-Middle Age preachers were on the
ReplyDeletecutting edge' of preaching for that time, not much has changed in the last 500-1000 years.
Am I off in my understanding of the history? Kirk/James/Jeff B?
So all that to say (sorry to 'preach' at you...) while early Church certainly met, it had little structure (as I understand it), and structure developed over time.
Thanks James, this is helping me to begin to land some on this issue.
you've probably studied it more but my grasp on historical preaching would be:
ReplyDeleteBiblical History
OT - read more and talk/interpret less (Moses, Josiah, etc.)
Gopsels/Jesus - high application/illustration but I'd say not all that different structure than what we do now...socratic method with the disciples but I don't see it so much with the crowd, lots of object lessons, lots of application but also lots of words (Feeding 5000 implies that he talked until they were hungry)...of course, Jesus wasn't boring and there was NO grammatical parsing, long background, etc.
NT/Paul in particular - just about everything...Paul putting people to sleep and talking all night...all night prayer vigils...also music (psalms, hymns, spiritual songs; early creeds/statements)
Post Biblical History
100-500+ AD - not a lot to work from but I think we have preserved sermons from some of the early church fathers
500ish-1500ish - long sermons in Latin (think we're bad, they weren't even talking in a language the people could understand)...granted this wasn't everyone but the bulk of the church until the Reformation
1500-1700 - Luther and Reformationists were preachers not too different from us but in German and singing songs with tunes taken from the bars
1700-1900 - long sermons that were typically read (Edwards, etc)...Spurgeon preached daily and twice on Sunday (in different cities from day to night) and people flocked to hear him...most of these were much like our sermons...the Wesley bros were leading the hymns here
1900+ - Dispensationalists (and eventually conservatives and Bible focused congregations) really pushed the "expositional" look at the languages and background (which is good for studying and a little overdone in the pulpit) and trudge through one verse, maybe two or even three if you're flying on a Sunday taking 3 years got get through a single book...typically that has come at the expense of application and actual understanding that leads to life change
that's what I see when I look back on history
From my reading/study I agree mostly with your scope on the history of preaching, at least in the major points. I would add that in every era once the homily was popularized (200AD+) that there were people preaching a 'high church' approach (i.e.e Latin, for the intellectual elite, formalized, etc) and others who were attempting to reach the average listener thru all approaches to creative preaching (these guys were usually persecuted in some fashion by the established church while loved by the masses). In all of that, it still seems that not much has changed in preaching in 1500 years. Honestly that saddens me some as well as give me a sense of passion about being an agent for preaching change. It's long overdue that we think of new approaches to the preaching task that are in 'the language' of our contemporary audiences. While the 'established' church may 'persecute; this I think it's time we make the 'homily' accessible to the people. I think it was Breese who said we ought to put "the Bread of Life on the lowest shelf" so that it would accessible to everyone!
ReplyDeletemaybe we just need to bring back blatant persecution/torture :-(
ReplyDeleteCertainly had a shaping, spreading, and growing influence on the church... but I'm not signing up.
ReplyDelete